Dear All,
The next talk in the "Wittgenstein=steine" series is this Friday (June
13th) at 3pm in room NIG 3D.
The speaker is Konstantin Deininger, and his title is:
_"On the Material and Formal Aspects of (Moral) Certainty"_.
Abstract:
Does morality have a binding character in the sense that chains of
justification come to an end? In this talk, I will affirm this question
and argue that we can plausibly distinguish between formal and material
aspects of moral certainty. As a starting point, I will interpret
Wittgenstein's idea of "bedrock," introduced in §217 of the
Philosophical Investigations, as standing for the end of a chain of
reasoning. In doing so, I align with certain Wittgensteinian
interpreters who maintain that some chains of moral reasoning end with
certainty. However, I will arrive at deviating conclusions by
demonstrating that different kinds of moral certainties function in
different ways. Wittgensteinian scholars such as Cora Diamond and Nigel
Pleasants correctly identify the formal aspect of moral certainty,
showing that some propositions resist justification and doubt. However,
the candidates for formal certainties they propose do not fully satisfy
the criteria of certainty. This, I argue, is due to their failure to
adequately distinguish between the formal and material aspects of
certainty. Material certainties, such as Diamond's "slavery is unjust
and insupportable" or Pleasants' "killing is wrong," remain intelligible
to some extent and are thus subject to justification and doubt. Still,
these propositions function as regress stoppers by putting an end to the
chain of reasoning--but they do not mark the boundary of the
unintelligible as formal certainties do. Drawing on Wittgenstein's later
writings, I will argue that only formal certainties--which I refer to as
transcendental certainties--are entirely exempt from justification and
doubt. I identify the principle "equals are to be treated equally" as a
plausible candidate for transcendental certainty. This certainty is
foundational to moral reasoning and enables moral thought. I illustrate
its role through debates on justice in animal ethics.
Everybody welcome!
Best wishes from the organizers,
Esther Heinrich-Ramharter
Anja Weiberg
Martin Kusch
Guten Tag!
Wir möchten Sie über folgende aktuelle Jobausschreibung am Institut für
Philosophie der Universität Wien informieren:
Organisationsassistent*in (6118)
Link zur Ausschreibung: <https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job-invite/6118/>
https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job-invite/6118/
Wir laden alle Interessierten herzlich dazu ein, sich für diese Position zu
bewerben.
Bitte leiten Sie diese Information auch an potenziell interessierte Personen
in Ihrem Umfeld weiter.
Vielen Dank im Voraus für Ihre Unterstützung!
Mit freundlichen Grüßen
Katherina Krobath
--
Institutskoordination
Dipl.-Ing. Katherina Geneviève Krobath, BEd
Andreas Wintersperger, MA
<mailto:philosophie@univie.ac.at> philosophie(a)univie.ac.at
+43(1)4277 46401
Institut für Philosophie
Universitätsstraße 7, Raum A316
1010 Wien
<https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/> https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/
Call for Applications: PhD in Philosophy at the University of Vienna
(30h/week, 4 years)
The FWF-funded research project “Bodies of Knowledge: Use-Based
Expertise Beyond Biomedicine” – PI: Sophie Juliane Veigl – invites
applications for a fully funded PhD Position.
Expected Start Date: Dec 2026 (with some flexibility)
About: Waning trust in science is often framed as a crisis of expertise.
Yet many communities beyond institutionalized medicine produce
sophisticated forms of knowledge through their engagement with
biomedical technologies. But are these knowers experts? And can current
philosophical understandings of expertise account for these forms of
knowledge? Bodies of Knowledge investigates how expertise is produced
and negotiated in communities that engage with steroid hormones beyond
conventional healthcare settings. Through a participatory research
design, the project integrates qualitative social science methods with
philosophical analysis. Current case studies examine steroid hormone use
by bodybuilders (PI-led) and DIY gender-affirming care (Postdoc-led).
The PhD Project: The successful applicant will develop an original
doctoral project within the broader research agenda of Bodies of
Knowledge. Applicants are invited to propose an empirical case study of
a community that uses steroid hormones. The proposed project may build
on one of the existing empirical contexts or investigate another
community. Applications should outline a case study the applicant would
be excited to pursue, explain its relevance for the project, and outline
how the applicant envisions approaching it empirically and
philosophically. The doctoral researcher will be supervised by Sophie
Juliane Veigl.
interested? more details on the post can be found on the application
website:
https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job/PhD-Position-in-Philosophy-in-FWF-Project-Bod…
If you have any questions, please contact:
sophie.juliane.veigl(a)univie.ac.at
--
Dr. Sophie Juliane Veigl, BSc., BA., MSc., MA.
Institut für Philosophie, Universität Wien
African Centre for Epistemology and Philosophy of Science, University of
Johannesburg
E-Mail: sophie.juliane.veigl(a)univie.ac.at
my pronouns are she/her
Dear all,
I am pleased to share with you the latest video featuring an
early-career researcher in the VDP, Mira Magdalena Sickinger.
In the video, How Humor Challenges Beliefs and Social Norms, Mira
presents her research on the role of humor in challenging beliefs and
social norms.
The video is available on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3X0oBK-fafI&t=1s
Kind regards,
Raphael Aybar
Good afternoon!
We would like to inform you about the following current job opening at the
Department of Philosophy at the University of Vienna:
University Assistant postdoctoral
in the research area of Sanskrit Philosophy (6109)
Link to the job posting: <https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job-invite/6109/>
https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job-invite/6109/
We warmly invite all interested individuals to apply for this position.
We would also greatly appreciate it if you could share this information with
potentially interested individuals in your network.
Thank you in advance for your support!
Kind regards,
Katherina Krobath
--
Institutskoordination
Dipl.-Ing. Katherina Geneviève Krobath, BEd
Andreas Wintersperger, MA
<mailto:philosophie@univie.ac.at> philosophie(a)univie.ac.at
+43(1)4277 46401
Institut für Philosophie
Universitätsstraße 7, Raum A316
1010 Wien
<https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/> https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/
Good afternoon!
We would like to inform you about the following current job opening at the
Department of Philosophy at the University of Vienna:
University Assistant Praedoc
in the research area of Sanskrit Philosophy (6068)
Link to the job posting: <https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job-invite/6068/>
https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job-invite/6068/
We warmly invite all interested individuals to apply for this position.
We would also greatly appreciate it if you could share this information with
potentially interested individuals in your network.
Thank you in advance for your support!
Kind regards,
Katherina Krobath
--
Institutskoordination
Dipl.-Ing. Katherina Geneviève Krobath, BEd
Andreas Wintersperger, MA
<mailto:philosophie@univie.ac.at> philosophie(a)univie.ac.at
+43(1)4277 46401
Institut für Philosophie
Universitätsstraße 7, Raum A316
1010 Wien
<https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/> https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/
Guten Tag!
Wir möchten Sie über folgende aktuelle Jobausschreibung am Institut für
Philosophie der Universität Wien informieren:
Organisationsassistent*in (6084)
Link zur Ausschreibung: https://jobs.univie.ac.at/job-invite/6084/
Wir laden alle Interessierten herzlich dazu ein, sich für diese Position zu
bewerben.
Bitte leiten Sie diese Information auch an potenziell interessierte Personen
in Ihrem Umfeld weiter.
Vielen Dank im Voraus für Ihre Unterstützung!
Mit freundlichen Grüßen
Katherina Krobath
--
Institutskoordination
Dipl.-Ing. Katherina Geneviève Krobath, BEd
Andreas Wintersperger, MA
<mailto:philosophie@univie.ac.at> philosophie(a)univie.ac.at
+43(1)4277 46401
Institut für Philosophie
Universitätsstraße 7, Raum A316
1010 Wien
<https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/> https://philosophie.univie.ac.at/